Explore Trending Add a recipe

Search for a dish

We don't cook ourselves. Every recipe links to the maker's website.

All dishes Trending Quick Add a recipe For recipe makers Privacy Terms

How the ranking works

Reviews here and stars on the maker's site, weighted by how trustworthy they are. A review with a photo counts for more; stars from a site that gives everything 5 stars count for less. Read how it works

English Nederlands Español Deutsch Français

Peanut butter cookies: the 11 best recipes compared · RankMyRecipe

The best peanut butter cookies

TimeQuick 5 Weeknight 10

DietVegetarian 10

LevelEasy 4 Medium 7

LanguageEnglish 10 Dutch 1

About Peanut butter cookies on RankMyRecipe

We compared 11 recipes for peanut butter cookies from 11 makers, with 566 reviews between them. Number 1 is the one by Food.com, with a RankMyRecipe score of 7.6. Short on time? The recipe by RecipeTin Eats is ready in 20 min.

11
recipes: 566
reviews at the makers: 20 min
fastest recipe

Ordered by RankMyRecipe score: reviews here and stars at the maker, weighted by how trustworthy they are. How it works

Pick what matters to you

Peanut butter cookies by Foodies

2Best match for your filters

Foodies

7.2

Not yet tested by RankMyRecipe cooks35 min

Best overall

Food.com

Fastest

RecipeTin Eats

20 min

Most reviewed at the maker

Natasha's Kitchen

135 reviews

Best vegetarian

Food.com

Easiest

Foodies

Baking: more dishes

Baking: all dishes

Brownies

24 recipes · 11,113 reviews

Banana bread

26 recipes · 9,056 reviews

Shortbread

15 recipes · 8,296 reviews

Carrot cake

23 recipes · 5,691 reviews

Brioche

12 recipes · 4,946 reviews

Apple pie

25 recipes · 4,839 reviews