Search for a dish

ExploreComfort food

The best shepherd's pie

About Shepherd's pie on RankMyRecipe

18
recipes: 1,902
reviews at the makers: 48 min
fastest recipe

Ordered by RankMyRecipe score: reviews here and stars at the maker, weighted by how trustworthy they are. How it works

#1rankmyrecipe

We don't cook ourselves. Every recipe links to the maker's website.

English Nederlands Español Deutsch Français

How the ranking works

Reviews here and stars on the maker's site, weighted by how trustworthy they are. A review with a photo counts for more; stars from a site that gives everything 5 stars count for less. Read how it works

English Nederlands Español Deutsch Français

Shepherd's pie: the 18 best recipes compared · RankMyRecipe

ExploreComfort food

The best shepherd's pie

About Shepherd's pie on RankMyRecipe

18
recipes: 1,902
reviews at the makers: 48 min
fastest recipe

Ordered by RankMyRecipe score: reviews here and stars at the maker, weighted by how trustworthy they are. How it works

Comfort food: more dishes

Comfort food: all dishes

The rest of the list

We compared 18 recipes for shepherd's pie from 18 makers, with 1,902 reviews between them. Number 1 is the one by Supergolden Bakes, with a RankMyRecipe score of 7.4. Short on time? The recipe by OhMyFoodness is ready in 48 min.

Pick what matters to you

TimeWeeknight 5 Weekend project 2

DietGluten-free 1

LevelMedium 4 Challenging 14

LanguageEnglish 15 Dutch 3

Clear filters

1Best match for your filters

Supergolden Bakes

7.4

Not yet tested by RankMyRecipe cooks1 h 40 min

View recipe

Delish

7.32 h

RecipeTin Eats

7.31 h 30 min

Olivia's Cuisine

5.0(2 reviews)2 h 15 min

7.3

Natasha's Kitchen

4.98(629 reviews)1 h 15 min

7.2

Downshiftology

4.98(227 reviews)1 h

7.2

Immaculate Bites

5.0(6 reviews)1 h 25 min

7.1

Lekker Tafelen

5.0(17 reviews)1 h 15 min

7.1

Cooking with Ria

5.0(2 reviews)1 h

7.1

OhMyFoodness

4.2(30 reviews)48 min

7.0

GialloZafferano

4.2(61 reviews)2 h 30 min

6.8

Marion's Kitchen

4.8(5 reviews)1 h 5 min

6.8

Once Upon a Chef

4.8(312 reviews)1 h 45 min

6.6

The Mediterranean Dish

4.25(4 reviews)1 h 35 min

6.4

Best overall

Supergolden Bakes

7.4

Fastest

OhMyFoodness

48 min

7.0

Most reviewed at the maker

Natasha's Kitchen

629 reviews

7.2

Comfort food: more dishes

Comfort food: all dishes

Philly cheesesteak

7 recipes · 21,739 reviews

7.4

Meatloaf

17 recipes · 13,999 reviews

8.0

Beef stew

27 recipes · 5,868 reviews

7.6

Chicken wings

16 recipes · 3,161 reviews

7.6

Quiche

12 recipes · 3,009 reviews

7.6

Chicken marsala

14 recipes · 2,758 reviews

7.6