We compared 5 recipes for sugar cookies from 5 makers, with 726 reviews between them. Number 1 is the one by Jo Cooks, with a RankMyRecipe score of 7.3. Short on time? The recipe by Love and Lemons is ready in 30 min.
2Best match for your filters
Best overall
Jo Cooks
Fastest
Love and Lemons
30 min
Most reviewed at the maker
Natasha's Kitchen
618 reviews
Easiest
24 recipes · 11,113 reviews
26 recipes · 9,056 reviews
15 recipes · 8,296 reviews
23 recipes · 5,691 reviews
12 recipes · 4,946 reviews
25 recipes · 4,839 reviews
