We compared 5 recipes for sugar cookies from 5 makers, with 726 reviews between them. Number 1 is the one by Jo Cooks, with a RankMyRecipe score of 7.3. Short on time? The recipe by Love and Lemons is ready in 30 min.
1Number 1 for sugar cookies
Delish
4.43(7 reviews)55 min
Food.com
4.5(17 reviews)1 h
Best overall
Jo Cooks
Fastest
Love and Lemons
30 min
Most reviewed at the maker
Natasha's Kitchen
618 reviews
Easiest
24 recipes · 11,113 reviews
26 recipes · 9,056 reviews
15 recipes · 8,296 reviews
23 recipes · 5,691 reviews
12 recipes · 4,946 reviews
25 recipes · 4,839 reviews
